Recognizing Burnout in Your Nonprofit Staff: A Guide to Keeping Your Team Strong

Working in a nonprofit is one of the most rewarding things you can do. There’s nothing quite like seeing the impact your organization is making in the community and knowing that you are a part of something bigger. However, as fulfilling as this work can be, it can also be emotionally taxing. Nonprofit employees often feel an intense sense of urgency to make a difference, which can lead to overwork and, eventually, burnout.

As a leader, it's crucial to recognize when your team might be headed toward burnout, and to step in before it reaches a critical stage. Burnout doesn't just affect one person—it impacts your entire team and can severely hinder your organization’s ability to meet its goals. Having experienced this firsthand while leading nonprofits, I know how essential it is to address the issue head-on.

What is Burnout?

Burnout is more than just feeling stressed or tired after a long week. It's a state of physical, emotional, and mental exhaustion, often accompanied by a feeling of doubt about your competence or the value of your work. At its core, burnout is the result of prolonged stress or frustration, and if left unchecked, it can lead to long-term emotional and physical exhaustion, chronic sadness, or even depression.

The Five Stages of Burnout

Understanding the stages of burnout can help you catch it early, both in yourself and your staff:


1. Honeymoon Phase: When a staff member starts a new role or project, they’re likely filled with excitement and energy. This phase is often marked by high productivity, creativity, and optimism. But as the novelty wears off, the stress begins to build. 

2. Onset of Stress: Slowly, the daily challenges begin to take their toll. Your staff may start experiencing anxiety, fatigue, headaches, and irritability. Their productivity may decline, and they might seem less eager to take on new tasks.

3. Chronic Stress: At this point, stress becomes a constant companion. Your employee may begin to isolate themselves socially, procrastinate more frequently, and feel physically and emotionally drained. They may turn to unhealthy coping mechanisms like excessive caffeine or alcohol use.

4. Burnout: The symptoms now reach a critical point where normal functioning becomes difficult. Burnout is characterized by feelings of emptiness, persistent negative thoughts, and physical exhaustion. Staff may start calling in sick more often, missing deadlines, or losing interest in their work.

5. Habitual Burnout: If burnout remains unaddressed, it can become a constant state of being. At this stage, your employee may face chronic exhaustion, sadness, paranoia and even depression. This deeply ingrained burnout requires significant recovery time as it becomes a part of their daily life.

The Consequences of Burnout

Burnout isn’t just tough on individuals—it’s tough on your organization. Burnt-out staff struggle to meet deliverables, and their declining performance can affect the overall morale of your team. If multiple staff members are experiencing burnout, it can create a toxic work environment, contributing to even more turnover. The cost of hiring and retraining new employees is high, so preventing burnout should be a priority.

How to Recognize Burnout in Your Team

Here are some key signs to watch for in your staff:

  • Chronic absenteeism or lateness

  • Decreased productivity and missed deadlines

  • Irritability, cynicism, or withdrawal from colleagues

  • Increased use of unhealthy coping mechanisms

  • Difficulty maintaining focus or enthusiasm for their work

Preventing Burnout: Steps You Can Take

Taking proactive steps to support your staff can prevent burnout before it becomes a problem. Here are a few ways to create a healthy work environment:

Set Boundaries: Make sure your team knows that after-hours communication isn’t expected. It’s crucial for employees to have time to disconnect from work. Encourage “unplugging” especially on vacation time and ensure working staff respect this. 

Celebrate Wins: Recognize your staff’s hard work regularly, whether through personal notes, small tokens of appreciation, or public recognition during meetings. 

Foster Connection: Encourage social time during work hours, like casual morning chats or monthly lunches. But avoid forcing after-hours events (forced fun) that can feel like an additional obligation.

Streamline Communication: Limit unnecessary emails and clearly define communication channels. For example, use scheduled emails if you’re working late to avoid overwhelming your team with a full inbox in the morning.

Provide Professional Development: Regularly check in with your staff about their goals, and make sure they’re getting the resources they need to grow in their roles.

Model Work-Life Balance: Your staff looks to you for guidance. If you’re constantly working late, they may feel pressure to do the same. Show them it’s okay to unplug by doing so yourself especially when on vacation.

My Personal Experience with Burnout

Having led nonprofits myself, I’ve been in the trenches and experienced burnout both personally and within my teams. Nonprofit work can feel all-consuming, and it's easy to put the mission above your own well-being. But I’ve learned that when we neglect our mental health, we’re not only doing a disservice to ourselves but also to the communities we’re trying to help.

When I started to see the toll, burnout was taking on me and my staff, I knew something had to change. By implementing some of the strategies above, I saw a significant improvement in team morale and productivity. It wasn’t easy, but it was worth it. This is why I’m passionate about helping other nonprofit leaders avoid the same pitfalls.

How I Can Help You
If you're concerned about burnout in your organization, I can help. Through Shoreline Advisors, I offer personalized coaching for nonprofit leaders who want to create a sustainable, healthy work culture for their teams. I’ve been there—I understand the challenges of nonprofit leadership and the pressure that comes with it.

Together, we can create actionable strategies to prevent burnout, foster a more balanced workplace, and ensure your team remains energized and committed to your mission.

Let’s connect and work on building a healthier future for your nonprofit. Reach out today for a free consultation to see how Shoreline Advisors can support you in leading your team through these challenges!

Kristin Fairholm, Shoreline Advisors

Previous
Previous

Reflecting on Resilience in Nonprofit Work: A Call for Compassion and Community Care

Next
Next

The Unfair Scrutiny of Non-Profit Leaders: A Call for Fairness and Understanding